The Healer
For much of human history, one of the most revered professions was that of the healer. This fearless individual was the one we turned to aid us in the that most terrible of all crises, when we faced death and had no defense other than their knowledge and skill to preserve us. In some ways, not much and everything has changed. Let me explain. Today's healers, physicians, doctors and other medical professionals do not easily fit the Marcus Welby archetype. They are not shamans, herbal dispensers or witchdoctors either. It would be dismissive of so many dedicated professionals who gave up a significant chunk of their lives to study and learn their craft to call them dispensers of drugs, yet that is often precisely what they do. It would be equally misleading to regard surgeons, radiologists, the entire range of specialists and practitioners as highly skilled crafts people, but they are no less so than the woodworker who carves a magnificent chest, or the mechanic that fixes your car, save for one thing. They alone hold life in the balance.
Please do not get me wrong. I honor these individuals. My Grandfather was a surgeon, the head of surgery at not one but two hospitals. He also had a practice in general medicine and made house calls in the days when doctors still did that. He practiced at a unique point in time, at the cusp of technological change that would transform his profession and unleash an unprecedented ability to peer inside the human body and see the mechanics of disease that were at work, when markers and tests could reveal disease long before it fully manifested, when the body of knowledge about our amazing life force expanded a thousand fold, and the options for treatment along with them.
In his day, physicians were so often detectives working with very limited tools. They pieced together clues, relied on the discoveries of their predecessors and most of all their experience to diagnose and treat; to stave off the predations of disease and death.
Compared to the present they operated in a dim and mysterious half light, and yet they cured the sick, rescued the dying from death's grip, performed what even today we would consider miracles.
Today, armed with vast knowledge and cutting edge technology that can literally manipulate human life at the cellular level, doctors still face the unknown--the diagnoses that no test reveals, the disease that pretends to be something else, the illness for which there is no remedy. It seems impossible to us as laymen when Doctor Google can tell us what's wrong with a few strokes of the keyboard and ai can offer a differential diagnoses in seconds. Except, all to often they are wrong, misleading, and sometimes dangerously so. But we'll turn to them in our desperation, and sometimes we'll trust these anonymous tipsters more than the flesh and blood physician standing before us.
And what of the healers, how has this incredible revolution in medicine changed for them. Surely it has made part of their job infinitely easier and more rewarding, hasn't it?
More people can be treated, more saved, isn't that what all these advances were intended to accomplish? Wouldn't that be wonderful if it were entirely true. But here's the thing, sometimes those advances don't end up healing, they end up hastening death. Pain killers create addictions, medications cause unforeseen complications, surgeries fail to fix what's broken and leave patients worse off than they were before. But even more to the point, in the wealthiest country on the planet, children and sometimes mothers die in childbirth at a rate far beyond most other countries. Here, life expectancy lags far behind peer nations, here chronic disease is under treated and manageable conditions like heart disease and diabetes are far more common than the rest of the world.
I do not blame the doctors. In our world, healers spend much of their precious time navigating the rules and regulations imposed by insurance companies that all too often dictate how, when, and if a patient is treated. More rules and regulations, created with the greatest intent as guardrails for treatment dictate even further restrictions. And the weight of all these impediments add an overhead of time, attention and cost that are almost never reflected in the quality of care or the outcomes patients receive.
To be clear, I am not advocating for socialized medicine although it does result in more and better care in much of the world than our approach. I do not wish to burden the point with politicized rhetoric , and some of the time, attention and rules are necessary to the practice of medicine even though they may not improve outcomes, or free physicians to focus on the healing and the saving of lives. But they should not be the overwhelming burden that makes healthcare unaffordable for millions, burns out physicians, and trades life for profit.
How would medicine be different in America if everyone involved, from insurance companies, to pharmaceutical firms, hospitals, and federal and state agencies were sworn to abide by the same oath as physicians, first do no harm?
Comments